Skip to main content

Contrasting living standard of the Dutch and Bhutan's Prime Ministers

. 14 Feb 18, Holland.  The Prime Minister of the Buddhist kingdom of Bhutan seems to be so scared of actual and perceived threats that he invested more than 3 million of the local currency in security arrangements for his new penthouse.


This was revealed by the Prime Minister Tshering Tobgay himself, during a press conference on 12th February. He reacted to a statement by the leader of the opposition party Druk Puensum Tshogpa; Dr. Pema Gyamtsho, agitatedly released a week earlier. Gyamtsho demanded a thorough investigation into the alleged misuse of public resources by the PM for the development of his private residence in the outskirts of capital city Thimphu. 'The use of public resources for private benefits', he said, 'is a serious form of corruption.


The perimeter of Prime Minister Tobgay’s residential area is protected by concrete walls of nine feet high. They are fitted with CCTV cameras and sophisticated security warning systems. Armed police forces guard the area continuously. The minister had commanded them to come up with a risk assessment. Based upon actual and perceived threats, they had to install complex security arrangements. At the same time, perhaps hypocritically, the Prime Minister told the state’s news bulletin Kuensel that ‘in a country like Bhutan, security should not be a concern’.

The government built a colony of extremely expansive residential villas or penthouses for the cabinet ministers in the Lhengay Densa area. But there is no obligation for the ministers to reside in this area. That's the reason why Tshering Tobgay chose to fortify his privately owned estate, complete with luxury arrangements in the name of security. The opposition party saw this as corruption, as public funds seemed to be misused. And what will happen with the expensive security installations when the tenure of the Prime Minister ends?. The former Prime Minister Jigme Yoeser Thinlay had similarly fortified his residence seemingly using the public fund, that 1 Million was invested for his kitchen and toilet alone.

In Bhutan’s controlled democracy, the powers of the opposition are limited. Nevertheless, it is good that it's allowed to raise its voice forcefully. After the opposition party had blamed Tobgay with misusing public resources, the government was compelled to involve the Auditing Authority and to prompt him to reimburse the funds. The question that remains: which perceived and actual threats endanger the life of the Prime Minister in this country of Gross National Happiness?

The Prime Minister didn't hesitate to threaten the opposition party to sue with charges of defamation, should the alleged corruption complaints prove to be fallacious, the Kuensel reported on 13th February yesterday. At the same time, the newspaper it mentioned that Tobgay had reimbursed the incurred expenses of his security arrangements. In fact, this seems to prove his guilt of misusing public funds.

In The Netherlands, a country though smaller than Bhutan and has more than 20 times the population of Bhutan, Minister President Mark Rutte used to live in a penthouse he rented. Recently it became known that he had signed for the purchase of that house though worth 1.3 million Euros in Benoordenhout. Installing security measures here, comparable to those of Bhutan’s Prime Minister has not become an issue. No opposition party would ever need to raise the issue of corruption. So, are the Bhutanese in the land of so called 'Gross National Happiness' feel happy and  safe as the Dutch?





(This article was first published in the RFG magazine. 

by: nanda Gautam. Holland

Labels:
Location: Gaki Lam, Thimphu, Bhutan

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Golden yoke and silken knot against Bhutan's democracy

13 July 2013 General election day. The early 16 th century’s two fold law codes of Shabdung; spiritual and temporal, that the former as a silken knot gradually becoming tighter and tighter, and the later as a golden yoke that is growing heavier and heavier, is bearing its obvious results in Bhutan’s constitutional democracy today, being it incorporated in the constitution. Despite the first five year democratic government machinery under the leadership of one of the most experienced aristocrat, the Prime Minister Jigme Yoeser Thinley, (April 2008 to May 2013) the true aspirations of the people fell unrecognised and continuously oppressed. Whether Naglong, Sarchop, Kheng or Lhotshamp; being a Bhutanese by birth and legal assimilation have the sanctimonious dignity based on the identity of the state and their own nomenclature as ‘Bhutanese’.  To keep this dignity upheld by the state is their true aspiration whatever the form of the government may be. For this, they all aspire to
Post a Comment
Read more

Angkor: The India’s great influence of the past in Cambodia

This is research report,  used to produce a documentary film by OHM en Rob Hof. The documentary was broadcasted on 12/12/2007 on Nederland1 TV Channel. Scroll down to see in English>> Dit is een van mijn literatuuronderzoek rapport voor  een documentairfilm.  Aan de hand van dit rapport over invloed van India in ASEAN heeft OHM en RobHof Film een documentair gemaakt. Het was uitdezonden op Nederlands 2 op 12 december 2007 zie die film:  India buiten India Angkor:    India buiten India Samenvatting van de repport. De tempels van Angkor zijn in circa negen honderd jaar geleden opgebouwd  door verscheidene Khmervorsten. Daardoor verschillen ze duidelijk in bouwstijl en zijn er zowel hindoeïstische als boeddhistische tempels te zien. Het was al jaren in de bos geheim gebleven.  In de loop van de jaren zijn er veel boeken verschenen over de tempel Angkor. Zo zijn er schrijvers geweest die beweren dat het een Boeddhistische tempel is. Anderen daarentegen
Post a Comment
Read more

Buddhist leader of Tibet, Dalai Lama coming closer to Krishna consciousness

23-3-17.   It is a great step forward to animal welfare and world peace at large that h ighly esteemed Buddhist head of abbot, the Dalai Lama of Tibet is coming closer to  Krishna consciousness . Dalai Lama with Indradymna Maharaj in Vrindavan His Holiness Dalai Lama presiding over the Tibetan government in exile in India visiting Vrindavan yesterday may not be a new anecdote but his hankering for the association of the pure devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Krishna and offer obeisance is remarkably a spiritual advancement that would go further from the Buddhist understanding of salvation as ‘ending up in zero or emptiness,  sunyata’  to the attainment of servitorship of the Lord Krishna personally, which is indeed more valuably pursued than the pursuit of the liberation,  mukti . According to the Vedic view point Buddhism is not a religion, in the sense that the Vedas guides its staunch followers attain its Supreme profounder, the God Krishna. But the Bud
Post a Comment
Read more